Appellate Law NJ Blog
  • Home
  • Bruce Greenberg

President Obama Nominates Rebecca Ross Haywood to the Third Circuit

Posted by Bruce D. Greenberg on Mar 17, 2016 in Third Circuit Court of Appeals | 0 comments

Somewhat overshadowed by the run-up to President Obama’s nomination yesterday of Judge Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court of the United States was the President’s nomination of Rebecca Ross Haywood, the day before, to fill a vacancy on the Third Circuit Court of Appeals.  The seat to be filled is one that became open when Judge Rendell took senior status.

Ms. Haywood, a Pennsylvania citizen, graduated cum laude from Princeton University and magna cum laude from the University of Michigan Law School.  She was on the law review at Michigan.  She then clerked for two years for a judge in the Western District of Pennsylvania, was an associate at Jones Day, and then became an Assistant United States Attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania, handling civil matters.  After holding that position for four years, Ms. Haywood went back to clerk for the same District Judge and then returned to the U.S. Attorney’s Office in 2003.  In 2010, she was promoted to Appellate Chief of that office, a position that she has held until today.

Like Judge Garland, Ms. Haywood has excellent credentials for the post to which she has been nominated, as Matthew Stiegler’s CA3 Blog documents here.  Predictably, Senator Pat Toomey (R-PA), who is up for re-election this year, has already come out against her nomination, asserting that Ms. Haywood is “not suitable for such an important lifetime position.”  Her record, discussed above and detailed in part here, appears to rebut that criticism.

Unlike in the case of Judge Garland, where a moderate Democrat has been nominated to fill the seat of an extremely conservative Republican, which is one of the objections asserted by Republicans to the Garland nomination, Ms. Haywood, a Democrat who would be the first African-American woman to sit on the Third Circuit, has been tapped to take the place of another Democratic woman judge.  Senator Toomey’s objection to Ms. Haywood thus seems even less well-founded and more opportunistic than most politically-based opposition to judicial nominees.  If a President cannot nominate a well-qualified woman to replace a woman of the same party on the Third Circuit, what appointment can a President make?

All judicial nominations are subject to the distortions of the election cycle.  Few if any nominations, especially at the Court of Appeals level, are likely to go through in a presidential election year.  President Obama and Ms. Haywood presumably both know that.  Nonetheless, it is unfortunate that such a worthy nominee probably will not get a hearing, due to the opposition of one of her home state Senators.  Pennsylvania’s other Senator, Bob Casey (D-PA), issued a ringing endorsement of Ms. Haywood’s nomination, one that, regrettably, will most likely fall on deaf ears.

 

 

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About the Author

Bruce D. Greenberg, a partner of Lite DePalma Greenberg & Afanador, LLC, has more than 35 years of appellate experience.  He has argued dozens of cases in New Jersey’s Appellate Division, and he has handled oral arguments in the Supreme Court of New Jersey and the Third Circuit Court of Appeals as well.  Mr. Greenberg’s appellate cases have ranged from . . more

 

Subscribe

  • reader reader
  • Subscribe to Appellate Law NJ Blog by Email

Archives

Links

  • An Appeal to Reason – California Appellate blog
  • Class Action Blawg
  • De Novo- Virginia Appellate Law blog
  • Florida Appellate Review
  • How Appealing
  • Maine Appeals Blog
  • New York Appellate Law blog
  • NJ Judiciary
  • On Brief – Iowa Appellate Law Blog
  • Third Circuit Blog
  • Third Circuit Court of Appeals

Categories

  • Administrative agency actions
  • Administrative matters
  • Appellate Division
  • Attorneys fees
  • Case management
  • Chancery issues
  • Class actions
  • Constitutional law
  • Consumer protection
  • Contract interpretation
  • Criminal law
  • Discovery
  • Effect of decisions by other courts
  • Judges
  • Jury issues
  • Municipal land use
  • Notable opinion writing
  • Pleadings
  • Practice Pointers
  • Standards of review
  • Statutory interpretation
  • Summary judgment
  • Supreme Court of New Jersey
  • Third Circuit Court of Appeals
  • Uncategorized
  • United States Supreme Court

Tags

Administrative agency actions Appendix Arbitration Briefs Chief Justice Stuart Rabner Court Rules Family Part interlocutory vs. final decisions Judge Allison Accurso Judge Anthony Parrillo Judge Carmen Alvarez Judge Carmen Messano Judge Clarkson Fisher Judge D. Brooks Smith Judge Douglas Fasciale Judge Ellen Koblitz Judge Heidi Willis Currier Judge Jack Sabatino Judge Jose Fuentes Judge Julio Fuentes Judge Marianne Espinosa Judge Marie Lihotz Judge Mary Catherine Cuff Judge Mitchel Ostrer Judge Patty Shwartz Judge Stephen Skillman Judge Susan Reisner Judge Thomas Ambro Judge Thomas Hardiman Judge Victor Ashrafi Justice Anne Patterson Justice Barry Albin Justice Faustino Fernandez-Vina Justice Helen Hoens Justice Jaynee LaVecchia Justice Lee Solomon Justice Roberto Rivera-Soto Justice Walter Timpone Law of the case Makeup of court Notice of appeal Prerogative writ appeals Standing Statute of limitations Waiver

Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by Wordpress