Appellate Law NJ Blog
  • Home
  • Bruce Greenberg

Appellate Division Ousts Morris County Freeholder in Resolving Election Dispute

Posted by Bruce D. Greenberg on Feb 7, 2012 in Administrative agency actions, Appellate Division, Judges, Standards of review | 0 comments

Nordstrom v. Lyon, 424 N.J. Super. 80 (App. Div. 2012).  William “Hank” Lyon was a media star last year.  In his early 20’s, and a newcomer to the political scene, Lyon ran for Morris County Freeholder (or, as his campaign materials put it, “for Conservative Freeholder”) in the Republican primary against four-term incumbent Margaret Nordstrom.  Lyon appeared to have scored an upset victory, by ten votes.  Nordstrom, however, challenged the election results, asserting voter misconduct and campaign financing and reporting improprieties by Lyon.  Nordstrom won in the Law Division and went on to win the November election and retain her Freeholder seat.  Lyon appealed, and the Appellate Division reversed in a lengthy opinion by Judge Harris.  The panel removed Nordstrom from her office and declared the Freeholder seat vacant.  Lyon demanded to be appointed in her place, but Judge Harris found no legal basis to do that.

Judge Harris recounted the facts in great detail.  In essence, however, the Law Division was found to have erred in ruling against Lyon for two reasons.  First, the alleged campaign contribution and reporting violations came within the purview of the New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission (“ELEC”), which had joined the case as an intervenor.  Under caselaw such as Muise v. GPU, Inc., 332 N.J. Super. 140 (App. Div. 2000), the Law Division erred in failing to defer to the primary jurisdiction of ELEC on the campaign contribution and reporting issues.  Judge Harris noted that the Law Division’s determination as to primary jurisdiction warranted no deference on appeal.

Second, as to the illegal voting allegations, Nordstrom was required to have shown (a) that enough illegal votes were cast so as to change the result if they had in fact been cast for Lyon, and (b) to the extent possible, for whom the illegal votes were cast.  Nordstrom produced at trial twelve voters whose mail-in ballots were “questionably cast.”  But no one asked those voters for whom they voted.  Thus, the panel concluded that “although illegal votes may indeed have been cast” in the primary election, they were not sufficient to change the result.  Therefore, the Law Division should not have ruled for Nordstrom on that issue.

In short, Lyon, not Nordstrom, should have been the Republican nominee in the 2011 Freeholder election.  Since that election had already occurred and Nordstrom had won the election and kept her seat, the remedy was to remove Nordstrom and declare her seat vacant.  Judge Harris found no basis for mandatorily “instat[ing Lyon] as the Morris County Freeholder” either for the balance of the term or on an interim basis.  That was so even though, as the Law Division “hinted,” victory in the Republican primary in Morris County was tantamount to election over the Democratic nominee.

Nordstrom seems certain to take this case to the Supreme Court, given its high visibility and the election law issues involved.  Meanwhile, Lyon is now back on top in this wrestling match.

No Responses to “Appellate Division Ousts Morris County Freeholder in Resolving Election Dispute”

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. NJ (campaign violations): Update: Nordstrom out, ELEC in, Lyon still unelected (for now) : State of Elections - [...] removing the need for party primaries over the summer.  Some NJ legal experts see this case reaching the New…

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About the Author

Bruce D. Greenberg, a partner of Lite DePalma Greenberg & Afanador, LLC, has more than 35 years of appellate experience.  He has argued dozens of cases in New Jersey’s Appellate Division, and he has handled oral arguments in the Supreme Court of New Jersey and the Third Circuit Court of Appeals as well.  Mr. Greenberg’s appellate cases have ranged from . . more

 

Subscribe

  • reader reader
  • Subscribe to Appellate Law NJ Blog by Email

Archives

Links

  • An Appeal to Reason – California Appellate blog
  • Class Action Blawg
  • De Novo- Virginia Appellate Law blog
  • Florida Appellate Review
  • How Appealing
  • Maine Appeals Blog
  • New York Appellate Law blog
  • NJ Judiciary
  • On Brief – Iowa Appellate Law Blog
  • Third Circuit Blog
  • Third Circuit Court of Appeals

Categories

  • Administrative agency actions
  • Administrative matters
  • Appellate Division
  • Attorneys fees
  • Case management
  • Chancery issues
  • Class actions
  • Constitutional law
  • Consumer protection
  • Contract interpretation
  • Criminal law
  • Discovery
  • Effect of decisions by other courts
  • Judges
  • Jury issues
  • Municipal land use
  • Notable opinion writing
  • Pleadings
  • Practice Pointers
  • Standards of review
  • Statutory interpretation
  • Summary judgment
  • Supreme Court of New Jersey
  • Third Circuit Court of Appeals
  • Uncategorized
  • United States Supreme Court

Tags

Administrative agency actions Arbitration Briefs Chief Justice Stuart Rabner Court Rules Family Part interlocutory vs. final decisions Judge Allison Accurso Judge Anthony Parrillo Judge Carmen Alvarez Judge Carmen Messano Judge Clarkson Fisher Judge D. Brooks Smith Judge Douglas Fasciale Judge Ellen Koblitz Judge Heidi Willis Currier Judge Jack Sabatino Judge Jose Fuentes Judge Julio Fuentes Judge Kent Jordan Judge Marianne Espinosa Judge Marie Lihotz Judge Mary Catherine Cuff Judge Michael Haas Judge Mitchel Ostrer Judge Stephen Skillman Judge Susan Reisner Judge Thomas Ambro Judge Thomas Hardiman Judge Victor Ashrafi Justice Anne Patterson Justice Barry Albin Justice Fabiana Pierre-Louis Justice Faustino Fernandez-Vina Justice Helen Hoens Justice Jaynee LaVecchia Justice Lee Solomon Justice Walter Timpone Law of the case Makeup of court Notice of appeal Prerogative writ appeals Standing Statute of limitations Waiver

Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by Wordpress