Appellate Law NJ Blog
  • Home
  • Bruce Greenberg

An LAD Opinion From the Supreme Court in a Disability Discrimination Case

Posted by Bruce D. Greenberg on Jul 12, 2017 in Judges, Notable opinion writing, Standards of review, Summary judgment, Supreme Court of New Jersey | 0 comments

Grande v. Saint Clare’s Health System, 230 N.J. 1 (2017).  Today’s unanimous, scholarly opinion by Justice Solomon, with an equally scholarly concurring opinion by Jsutice LaVecchia, arose from an appeal as of right in this Law Against Discrimination (“LAD”) case.  The Appellate Division split 2-1 as to whether there were genuine issues of material fact for trial, with the majority concluding that there were such issues.  The defendant, Saint Clare’s, appealed, and the Supreme Court found that there were disputed material issues for trial.  The Court affirmed the decision below as modified, and remanded the matter to the Law Division for further proceedings.

This was more than just a fact-intensive analysis of the circumstances of this particular case, which involved a disabled employee.  The two opinions evaluated whether this was a direct evidence case or a circumstantial evidence case, since the standards for the two types of case differ.  The Court also resolved the previously-unaddressed issue of where in the legal analysis is the proper place to consider whether a reasonable accommodation would have allowed the disabled employee to perform her job.  Justice Solomon concluded that a prong of the analysis that looks at whether the employee was in fact performing her job, or whether, with or without reasonable accommodations, the employee was able to perform her job to the employer’s legitimate expectations.

In short, both opinions in this case are must reading for anyone involved in LAD cases, especially those involving claims by disabled employees.  Though the opinions total 60 pages, they are well worth the time to absorb them in full.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About the Author

Bruce D. Greenberg, a partner of Lite DePalma Greenberg, LLC, has more than 35 years of appellate experience.  He has argued dozens of cases in New Jersey’s Appellate Division, and he has handled oral arguments in the Supreme Court of New Jersey and the Third Circuit Court of Appeals as well.  Mr. Greenberg’s appellate cases have ranged from . . more

 

Subscribe

  • reader reader
  • Subscribe to Appellate Law NJ Blog by Email

Archives

Links

  • An Appeal to Reason – California Appellate blog
  • Appellate Briefs
  • Class Action Blawg
  • De Novo- Virginia Appellate Law blog
  • Fast Five on Rhode Island Appellate Practice
  • Florida Appellate Review
  • How Appealing
  • Maine Appeals Blog
  • New York Appellate Law blog
  • NJ Judiciary
  • On Brief – Iowa Appellate Law Blog
  • Third Circuit Blog
  • Third Circuit Court of Appeals

Categories

  • Administrative agency actions
  • Administrative matters
  • Appellate Division
  • Attorneys fees
  • Case management
  • Chancery issues
  • Class actions
  • Constitutional law
  • Consumer protection
  • Contract interpretation
  • Criminal law
  • Discovery
  • Effect of decisions by other courts
  • Judges
  • Jury issues
  • Municipal land use
  • Notable opinion writing
  • Pleadings
  • Practice Pointers
  • Standards of review
  • Statutory interpretation
  • Summary judgment
  • Supreme Court of New Jersey
  • Third Circuit Court of Appeals
  • Uncategorized
  • United States Supreme Court

Tags

Administrative agency actions Appendix Arbitration Briefs Chief Justice Stuart Rabner Court Rules Family Part Grammar interlocutory vs. final decisions Judge Anthony Parrillo Judge Carmen Messano Judge Clarkson Fisher Judge D. Brooks Smith Judge Douglas Fasciale Judge Edwin Stern Judge Ellen Koblitz Judge Jack Sabatino Judge Jose Fuentes Judge Julio Fuentes Judge Kent Jordan Judge Marianne Espinosa Judge Marie Lihotz Judge Mary Catherine Cuff Judge Michael Haas Judge Mitchel Ostrer Judge Patty Shwartz Judge Stephen Skillman Judge Susan Reisner Judge Thomas Ambro Judge Thomas Hardiman Judge Thomas Vanaskie Judge Victor Ashrafi Justice Anne Patterson Justice Barry Albin Justice Helen Hoens Justice Jaynee LaVecchia Justice Lee Solomon Justice Roberto Rivera-Soto Law of the case Makeup of court Notice of appeal Prerogative writ appeals Standing Statute of limitations Waiver

Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by Wordpress